FRCS (ORL-HNS) · SECTION 1 SBA

Empty nose syndrome risk

A patient requests complete inferior-turbinate removal for nasal obstruction despite normal-sized turbinates and a narrow internal valve. What is the best surgical principle?

CHOOSE ONE ANSWER

Best of five

  1. A. Remove both inferior turbinates completely
  2. B. Guarantee unrestricted airflow
  3. C. Perform surgery without objective examination
  4. D. Ignore the patient's goals
  5. E. Identify the true site of obstruction and preserve functional turbinate mucosa
ANSWER AND REASONING

E. Identify the true site of obstruction and preserve functional turbinate mucosa

Over-resection can impair humidification and airflow sensation and cause paradoxical obstruction. Treatment should address the valve or other demonstrated cause while preserving mucosa.

Why every option is right or wrong

A. Remove both inferior turbinates completely: Radical resection risks dryness, crusting and empty-nose symptoms.

B. Guarantee unrestricted airflow: Subjective obstruction has multiple determinants and cannot be guaranteed.

C. Perform surgery without objective examination: Endoscopy and functional assessment are needed.

D. Ignore the patient's goals: Shared decision-making remains essential even when declining an inappropriate operation.

E. Identify the true site of obstruction and preserve functional turbinate mucosa: Over-resection can impair humidification and airflow sensation and cause paradoxical obstruction. Treatment should address the valve or other demonstrated cause while preserving mucosa.

What if the scenario changed?

If marked irreversible turbinate hypertrophy persisted after optimal medical treatment, conservative volume-reduction surgery could be discussed.

EDUCATIONAL USE

Independent Clinora educational preparation material; not official JCIE content, an accredited programme, clinical advice, or a substitute for current guidance, local policy and specialist judgement.

Back to the Section 1 bank