FRCS (ORL-HNS) · SECTION 1 SBA

Nodal sampling technique

An adult has a suspicious level II cervical node and a possible tonsillar primary. Which initial tissue strategy is most appropriate?

CHOOSE ONE ANSWER

Best of five

  1. A. Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration or core biopsy of the node
  2. B. Open node biopsy before imaging
  3. C. Complete tonsillectomy without sampling the node
  4. D. Observation because HPV-positive nodes grow slowly
  5. E. Treat with radiotherapy without histological confirmation
ANSWER AND REASONING

A. Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration or core biopsy of the node

NICE recommends considering ultrasound guidance for FNAC or core biopsy of a suspected malignant neck lump. This establishes histology while preserving neck planes and allows HPV-related testing where appropriate.

Why every option is right or wrong

A. Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration or core biopsy of the node: NICE recommends considering ultrasound guidance for FNAC or core biopsy of a suspected malignant neck lump. This establishes histology while preserving neck planes and allows HPV-related testing where appropriate.

B. Open node biopsy before imaging: Open biopsy may disrupt future neck-dissection fields and should not be the routine first step.

C. Complete tonsillectomy without sampling the node: The node provides a readily accessible route to diagnosis and informs the occult-primary pathway.

D. Observation because HPV-positive nodes grow slowly: HPV-related disease still requires prompt diagnosis and staging.

E. Treat with radiotherapy without histological confirmation: Definitive treatment requires tissue diagnosis except in extraordinary circumstances.

What if the scenario changed?

If needle sampling were repeatedly non-diagnostic despite radiological suspicion, the MDT would plan further tissue acquisition rather than defaulting to observation.

EDUCATIONAL USE

Independent Clinora educational preparation material; not official JCIE content, an accredited programme, clinical advice, or a substitute for local policy and specialist judgement.

Back to the Section 1 bank