FRCS (ORL-HNS) · SECTION 1 SBA

Salvage laryngectomy after radiotherapy

A fit patient has biopsy-proven isolated recurrent T3 glottic carcinoma two years after definitive radiotherapy, with a functional but threatened larynx and no metastases. What offers the best chance of cure?

CHOOSE ONE ANSWER

Best of five

  1. A. Repeat full-dose radiotherapy routinely
  2. B. Salvage total laryngectomy with reconstruction planned for the irradiated field
  3. C. Endoscopic biopsy alone
  4. D. Chemotherapy alone with curative expectation
  5. E. Observation until airway obstruction
ANSWER AND REASONING

B. Salvage total laryngectomy with reconstruction planned for the irradiated field

For resectable substantial recurrence after full-dose radiotherapy, salvage laryngectomy is the principal curative option; vascularised tissue may reduce fistula risk and rehabilitation must be planned.

Why every option is right or wrong

A. Repeat full-dose radiotherapy routinely: Re-irradiation can be considered selectively but is not the default curative option for resectable bulky intralaryngeal recurrence.

B. Salvage total laryngectomy with reconstruction planned for the irradiated field: For resectable substantial recurrence after full-dose radiotherapy, salvage laryngectomy is the principal curative option; vascularised tissue may reduce fistula risk and rehabilitation must be planned.

C. Endoscopic biopsy alone: Biopsy establishes diagnosis but does not treat T3 recurrent disease.

D. Chemotherapy alone with curative expectation: Systemic therapy alone is generally non-curative for an isolated resectable recurrence.

E. Observation until airway obstruction: Delay risks loss of resectability, aspiration and emergency airway compromise.

What if the scenario changed?

If disease encased the carotid with distant metastases and no realistic curative route, symptom-directed systemic and palliative care planning would take precedence.

EDUCATIONAL USE

Independent Clinora educational material; not official JCIE content, an accredited programme, clinical advice, or a substitute for local policy and specialist judgement.

Back to the Section 1 bank