FRCS (ORL-HNS) · SECTION 1 SBA

Nasopharyngeal carcinoma response assessment

A patient completes chemoradiotherapy for EBV-associated nasopharyngeal carcinoma. At 12 weeks, MRI shows post-treatment thickening without a discrete mass, examination is unremarkable and plasma EBV DNA is undetectable. What is the best approach?

CHOOSE ONE ANSWER

Best of five

  1. A. Immediate total nasopharyngectomy
  2. B. Declare complete cure and stop follow-up
  3. C. Start empirical chemotherapy for the thickening
  4. D. Rely on EBV DNA alone forever
  5. E. Structured clinical and imaging surveillance rather than immediate blind salvage biopsy
ANSWER AND REASONING

E. Structured clinical and imaging surveillance rather than immediate blind salvage biopsy

Early post-treatment change can mimic tumour. Concordant endoscopy, imaging evolution and EBV DNA should guide targeted biopsy; unplanned deep biopsy can be morbid and low yield.

Why every option is right or wrong

A. Immediate total nasopharyngectomy: There is no confirmed persistent tumour to justify radical salvage surgery.

B. Declare complete cure and stop follow-up: Late recurrence and treatment toxicity still require specialist surveillance.

C. Start empirical chemotherapy for the thickening: Non-specific post-treatment change without evidence of viable disease is not an indication for systemic treatment.

D. Rely on EBV DNA alone forever: The biomarker complements but does not replace examination and imaging.

E. Structured clinical and imaging surveillance rather than immediate blind salvage biopsy: Early post-treatment change can mimic tumour. Concordant endoscopy, imaging evolution and EBV DNA should guide targeted biopsy; unplanned deep biopsy can be morbid and low yield.

What if the scenario changed?

If a focal enlarging enhancing lesion and renewed detectable EBV DNA appeared on serial review, directed biopsy for suspected persistence or recurrence would be required.

EDUCATIONAL USE

Independent Clinora educational material; not official JCIE content, an accredited programme, clinical advice, or a substitute for local policy and specialist judgement.

Back to the Section 1 bank