A professional singer is considering thyroid surgery for a compressive benign goitre. She asks specifically about the chance of a permanent voice change and whether non-operative management remains possible. What is the best response?
GMC guidance requires information tailored to what matters to this individual. A signed form or generic complication list cannot substitute for a conversation about the outcome that may be particularly significant to her.
A. Provide a standard leaflet and obtain a signature: Documentation alone does not establish informed decision making.
B. State that the risk is too small to discuss: Materiality includes what this patient is likely to attach significance to.
C. Withhold alternatives because surgery is recommended: Reasonable alternatives, including doing nothing when applicable, should be discussed.
D. Ask the anaesthetist to obtain consent on the day: The surgeon should discuss the procedure-specific benefits, risks, limitations and alternatives.
E. Discuss the material voice risk, reasonable alternatives and uncertainty in a documented shared decision: GMC guidance requires information tailored to what matters to this individual. A signed form or generic complication list cannot substitute for a conversation about the outcome that may be particularly significant to her.
If urgent life-saving treatment were required and the patient lacked capacity, the immediate legal and ethical framework would be different.
Draft Clinora educational material only; not official JCIE content, an accredited programme, or a substitute for local policy and specialist judgement.
Back to the Section 1 bank